A new future for hip fracture care – orthogeriatrician lead in an ‘Acute’ Hip Unit
ABSTRACT
Although surgery is the definitive treatment for almost all hip fractures, there is evidence that outcomes such as morbidity and mortality are not determined by the type of surgery but by comorbidities and postoperative complications. A team approach, especially the involvement of an orthogeriatrician in managing medical issues, has been shown to improve surgical outcomes and should be encouraged in hospitals worldwide. An Acute Hip Unit is able to address the complex challenging needs of a frail older high-risk population soon after admission, therefore minimising delays. An orthogeriatrician-led unit can deal with the preoperative and complex postoperative medical, social, ethical, physical, and mental health issues that are associated with ‘hip fracture syndrome’, providing structured standardised evidence-based care by trained staff. This could be the model of care for the future.
Key points
Hip fracture surgery is only one aspect amongst the multiple complexities of ‘Hip fracture syndrome’.
Hip fractures are traditionally managed by surgeons but orthogeriatricians can play a key role in managing complex medical, social, and ethical conditions.
Prevention, early recognition and management of comorbidities and complications by orthogeriatric specialists are the key towards improving outcomes.
Orthogeriatricians can provide specialist input on falls prevention and osteoporosis management, and can lead multidisciplinary teams that support rehabilitation and recovery.
An orthogeriatrician-led Acute Hip Unit model can address several complex medical pre- and postoperative issues, providing standardised care in one ward even though surgical fixation is performed by different surgeons.
An Acute Hip Unit provides focussed, multidisciplinary, holistic, seamless and specialized early care by a trained staff, meeting national care standards.
An Acute Hip Unit care model is feasible across many UK hospitals.
Introduction
Hip fractures pose a major public health burden and consume significant healthcare resources; the incidence of hip fractures is expected to rise with the ageing population and is already the second most frequent cause of hospitalisation in the older population.1 Hip fractures are associated with a significant increase in morbidity and mortality for both the short-term (3 to 6 months) and the long-term (5 to 10 years).2 A meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies found a five- to eight-fold increase in mortality rates within three months of fracture and estimated a one-year mortality range between 14% and 36%.3
Of those who survive one year after hip fracture, only 40% can perform all routine activities of daily living and only 54% can walk without an aid.4 Many patients require long-term nursing care, posing a challenge to both health and social care resources. The high impact of hip fracture probably results from a combination of trauma, major surgery, medical problems and low physiological reserve. Although surgery is the main treatment for a fracture of the hip, the orthogeriatrician has a key role in the further holistic management of the patient's medical comorbidities and complications during the perioperative period, and this specialist medical care can improve outcomes. In this article we present evidence indicating what care should be provided to those with hip fractures and how it should be delivered, and report how these findings have come together in the development of an Acute Hip Fracture Unit.
Benefits of geriatrician-led perioperative medical management
Patients with hip fractures have multiple complexities and are managed by several specialities, so there is a potential for miscommunication, delays and gaps in patient care. The National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE) in the UK has recommended that, beginning at admission, hip fracture patients should be offered a formal acute orthopaedic- or orthogeriatric-ward-based hip fracture programme, which includes orthogeriatric assessment.5 A formal Hip Fracture Programme, incorporating continuous orthogeriatric supervision and providing a co-ordinated structure and process of care, is more effective than a Geriatric Orthopaedic Rehabilitation Unit model or standard orthopaedic care.5 Geriatrician-led management for hip fracture patients can lead to significant reduction in both postoperative complications and mortality,6,7 and has also been shown to reduce length of stay in hospital.8,9
A study of a co-managed Hip Fracture Programme that began at admission showed that for every 1,000 patients treated in a geriatric model there were 17 fewer in-hospital deaths, 871 fewer complications and 97 fewer 30-day re-admissions than was the case for 1,000 patients treated with standard care; this provides enormous financial benefits with the Hip Fracture Programme incurring only 66.7% of the expected costs.10
Where this care is delivered also has an impact on outcome: daily medical interventions were shown to reduce mortality whereas less-intensive interventions may not be as consistent in reducing medical complications.8 Focused multidisciplinary specialised care, covering the relatively homogenous hip fracture population within a defined geographic region, such as that which might be provided by an Acute Orthogeriatric Hip Unit, could improve outcomes, as has been the case for Stroke Units.11
Preoperative optimisation to enable early surgery
Reducing delays before surgery can reduce mortality and complications, as shown by a meta-analysis that found that earlier surgery is associated with a lower risk of death and with lower rates of postoperative pneumonia and pressure sores amongst older patients with hip fracture.12 Time to surgery can be reduced by the proactive identification and management of comorbid conditions and geriatric syndromes. Hip fractures occur mostly in the older population, with an average age at presentation of 84 years for men and 83 years for women; concurrent medical problems are common in this population. Unlike their younger contemporaries, older patients have a loss of functional reserve and a decline in organ function; it has been reported that 82% of patients have a significant medical condition that complicated a hip fracture.13 The altered physiological state, coupled with comorbidities, can be difficult to manage and increases perioperative risk.
Patients in classes 3 (severe systemic disease) and 4 (severe systemic disease that is a constant threat to life) of the American Society of Anaesthesiologists (ASA) Physical Status System have increased medical complications in the postoperative period, suggesting that these patients need to be closely managed medically,14 and any issues need to be addressed early in the preoperative stage.
Close liaison with the surgeon and anaesthetist about murmurs, cardiac findings and polypharmacy will help avoid routine tests that will not affect the surgical procedure. This, combined with the development of management protocols for common anticipated medical problems, will enable early surgery to take place. These findings support the importance of effective medical assessment and optimisation in the preoperative period.
Postoperative complications: early identification and management
Postoperative complications are common in hip fracture patients, amongst a population of more than 2,000 patients in a UK hospital followed prospectively, postoperative complications occurred in 20% of patients. Patients who had acute heart failure or postoperative chest infection had high 30-day mortality rates of 65% and 43%, respectively.15 Monitoring, early identification and management of complications by the orthogeriatric team can improve outcomes for these frail older patients.
A number of common complications are often managed by the orthogeriatric team. A management strategy based on a comprehensive geriatric assessment ensures that multiple complex issues are managed efficiently and that interventions are tailored to individual patient needs.
Delirium
Delirium is commonly seen following hip fracture and occurs in up to 61% of patients, it is more common in patients with dementia.16 Delirium is a serious medical condition and increases the risk of poor outcomes, including surgical complications, mortality and institutionalisation.17 Delirium also delays functional recovery and hence affects the rehabilitation process. There are often multiple causes of delirium and many of the precipitating factors (Box 1) can be identified early so that treatment can be initiated proactively. There are many modifiable factors, such as management of electrolyte disturbances, treatment of infection, adequate analgesia and medication review. As noted in several studies,18–20 proactive orthogeriatric consultation can reduce the incidence and severity of delirium in hip fracture patients; nearly one-third of delirium incidences are completely preventable.17 In managing postoperative delirium, a holistic approach is needed as cause of the delirium is commonly multifactorial. Patients often require several targeted interventions, depending on their history and examination findings. The orthogeriatrician has an essential role in ensuring that serious medical conditions are not missed.
Malnutrition
About 23% of patients with hip fractures are severely malnourished, and consequently can have muscle wasting, mental apathy and impaired cardiac function. Malnutrition results in impaired mobility and a tendency to postoperative complications and increased mortality.21
Anaemia and inappropriate fluid status
Anaemia is common in older people and is an independent risk factor for increased mortality, postoperative complications, poor functional outcome, and increased length of stay.22 Patients with symptomatic anaemia, especially those with known cardiac disease, require blood transfusion to keep haemoglobin levels at more than 80 g/l.23
Problems with polypharmacy
Polypharmacy is common in older patients whose medication regimes are often complex. An orthogeriatrician would routinely review medications for their dosage, indication, side effects and interactions.
Dementia
Dementia is noted in up to 19% of patients with hip fractures but cognitive impairment is found in up to 42% of patients.24 Cognitively impaired patients have longer length of hospital stay and higher physical dependence, mortality and institutionalisation.25 Assessment of cognitive status is complex if patients are in pain, and pain control for hip fracture patients may be suboptimal because of poor self-reporting of pain. Cognitively impaired patients also benefit from comprehensive geriatric assessment and targeted intervention as a means of reducing delirium.26
Box 1. Precipitating factors for delirium.
Bladder and bowel problems
Urinary tract infection, urinary retention and incontinence are common postoperative problems following a hip fracture. Removal of urinary catheters the morning after surgery is likely to reduce the chances of urinary retention27 and also aids in early mobilisation. The diagnosis of constipation should be actively pursued and treated because this is more common in the postoperative period due to analgesia, immobility and dehydration.
Pain
Optimal pain control is essential so that patients can engage with rehabilitation. Patients with poorly controlled perioperative pain are likely to have increased length of stay and increased 6-month mortality.28 A Cochrane review has shown that nerve blocks can reduce the need for analgesic drugs and are effective for pain relief in hip fracture patients.29
Other specialist roles of the orthogeriatrician working with hip fracture patients
Osteoporosis management
The majority of hip fractures in the elderly are associated with osteoporosis,30 and following the fracture, risk factors for osteoporosis need to be addressed (Box 2). Orthogeriatricians have the expert knowledge and skills necessary for osteoporosis assessment and management, and this input from an orthogeriatrician can increase osteoporosis treatment in hip fracture patients from 12 to 69%.13
Several effective drugs are available for the management of osteoporosis and can reduce recurrent fractures (Box 3). Routine bone mineral density testing by dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) is not recommended by NICE in the UK for female patients above the age of 75 years,5 but a clinical diagnosis can be made. Male patients are more likely to have secondary osteoporosis, whose associated and causative conditions would need to be addressed by an orthogeriatrician. Issues of recurrent fractures, atypical fracture, poor compliance, dental side effects, contraindications to bisphosphonate use, DEXA scan interpretation, and abnormal bone metabolism blood results can be addressed effectively by an orthogeriatrician.
Box 2. Common risk factors for osteoporosis.
Box 3. Drugs for osteoporosis.
Assessment and management of falls
A full falls assessment should be undertaken routinely by the orthogeriatrician. The circumstances leading to the fall need to be assessed with a detailed history and examination, which should include a history of syncope and factors contributing to the fall (Box 4). An orthogeriatrician would have links with the falls or syncope services available locally, ensuring timely and appropriate referrals.
Rehabilitation
A majority of patients do not return to pre-morbid activities of daily living after hip fracture. In one study, only 74% fully recovered walking ability and 56% returned to pre-fracture physical activities after one year; patients who were older and those with delirium after surgery recovered the least.31
Rehabilitation after hip fracture is essential to aid recovery and to prevent functional decline. Under the supervision of an orthogeriatrician, rehabilitation should begin on the first postoperative day. Early mobilisation should be encouraged to prevent chest infections, deep vein thrombosis and pressure sores. During discharge planning, a complex maze of cognitive, functional and social issues, the effects of acute and long-term medical comorbidities, the complexities of recovery from surgery, and the wishes of the patient and their family must be unravelled by an orthogeriatrician. The aims of rehabilitation should be to maximise potential within the hospital setting and then enable return to pre-admission residence by early supported discharge. Randomised trial data show that geriatric rehabilitation programs increase the likelihood of patients returning to the community.32 The relationship between rehabilitation program and functional gain in patients with cognitive impairment is complex. A systematic review showed beneficial effects of a rehabilitation programme on physical function in cognitively impaired patients,33 hence rehabilitation after hip fracture is mandatory even for cognitively impaired patients.
Box 4. Common risk factors for falls.
Complex ethical issues
Orthogeriatricians have a holistic approach to care for seriously ill patients and can advise on an appropriate approach towards end of life care, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, and the need for intensive care, coronary care, and ventilation. Depending on the patient's clinical condition, they can facilitate early decisions on complex issues. Early communication with the patient and their family is necessary, a process that is very familiar to the orthogeriatric team. A palliative-care approach, in liaison with the local palliative care team if needed, would mean that patients and their families have minimal distress and receive adequate support.
UK national standards approach
Joint acute orthogeriatric co-management is recommended by NICE5 and by the British Orthopaedic Association and the British Geriatric Society.34 Shared surgical and medical care for hip fractures is increasingly being implemented and adopted across UK hospitals and worldwide.35 In the UK, a large audit database, The National Hip Fracture Database (NHFD), collects data about the organisation and processes involved in the pre- and postoperative care of hip fracture admissions across all hospitals in England and Wales; it has shown progressive improvements in hip fracture care.36 The latest NHFD report (2014) showed that 47% of hip fracture patients are assessed preoperatively by a geriatrician (up from 43% in 2013); 69% received bone protection medication and 94% received falls assessment (up from 92% in 2013).36
First Acute Hip Unit in Wales
The author (AG) developed an orthogeriatrician-led 15-bedded collaborative Acute Hip Unit in 2011 at Glangwili Hospital, Carmarthen, Wales; it was the first of its kind in Wales.37 The unit was modelled on Acute Coronary Care and Stroke Units, with dedicated ring-fenced beds, direct admission from the emergency department, standard protocols and care, staff training, and consistent senior medical cover. This unit has reduced length of stay and improved quality through the provision of standardised care.38 Fast-track protocols and the clerking of patients using a standardised clerking proforma in the Acute Hip Unit reduce the time spent in the emergency department, and allow data collection for audit and improvement purposes. A unit managed by just one geriatrician has led to the development of high-quality, structured, standardised, evidence-based care in managing the ‘medical’ issues of patients under the care of several surgeons, thereby reducing the chances of variable care and minimising preoperative delay.
Weekly multidisciplinary meetings led by a consultant geriatrician and increased daily medical supervision have reduced the units dependency on the on-call medical registrar, allowing sick patients to be managed consistently with earlier detection and management of delirium. This unit allows seamless preoperative and early postoperative care in the same environment.
Uniquely, in the new unit, care is shared between orthopaedic and medical juniors. This has improved training opportunities for orthopaedic juniors in assessing elderly patients’ comorbidity, polypharmacy, falls and osteoporosis. The nursing staff also previously had an ‘orthopaedic background’ but now have a more specialised training and approach in dealing with both medical and surgical issues. Team working has improved considerably and improved morale and satisfaction is noted by the staff and patients. There is improved documentation of communication with patients, relatives and multidisciplinary professionals, and patients are provided with written information leaflets. Our experience shows that the social problems experienced by older hip fracture patients are the most difficult to tackle. This has been addressed by identifying problems proactively and by starting to plan possible solutions by coordinating with other professionals, agencies, the patient and their family; and by trying to minimise wastage of time and resources.
This model of care proves that cross-departmental working is achievable by reorganisation of existing resources available in an average district general hospital in the UK. With the rising demand for beds in acute hospitals in UK, this unit is an example of innovation in the care of hip fracture patients.
Conclusions
To reduce morbidity and mortality from hip fractures, attention must focus on optimising medical conditions preoperatively, on early surgery, and on preventing postoperative complications by early recognition and by providing specialist medical care throughout. During the perioperative period following a hip fracture, there are several areas of medical management that can be addressed optimally by an orthogeriatrician working together with the surgeon. Orthogeriatricians have specialist expertise in dealing with common medical issues, especially aspects of rehabilitation, falls recognition and prevention, secondary osteoporosis management and early recognition and management of delirium. Increasingly, and with good evidence to support them, orthogeriatric units are being set up in which care is shared between surgeons and an orthogeriatrician. An orthogeriatrician-led Acute Hip Unit model of care has many advantages and could feasibly be introduced into many hospitals by reorganisation of existing resources. This new care model has the potential to reduce morbidity and mortality in the frail hip fracture population.
Acknowledgements
We thank all of the staff of the Carmarthen Acute Hip Unit for their support in setting up the Unit.
- © 2014 Royal College of Physicians
References
- 1.↵
- 2.↵
- 3.↵
- 4.↵
- 5.↵
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence
- 6.↵
- 7.↵
- 8.↵
- 9.↵
- 10.↵
- 11.↵
- Hill M
- 12.↵
- Simunovic N,
- Devereaux PJ,
- Sprague S,
- et al.
- 13.↵
- 14.↵
- Donegan DJ,
- Gay N,
- Baldwin K,
- et al.
- 15.↵
- Roche JJW,
- Wenn RT,
- Sahota O,
- Moran CG
- 16.↵
- 17.↵
- 18.↵
- Siddiqui N,
- Holl R,
- Bitton AM,
- Holman J
- 19.↵
- 20.↵
- 21.↵
- 22.↵
- 23.↵
- 24.↵
- 25.↵
- Bentler SE,
- Liu L,
- Obrizan M,
- et al.
- 26.↵
- 27.↵
- 28.↵
- 29.↵
- Parker MJ,
- Griffiths R,
- Appadu BN
- 30.↵
- 31.↵
- 32.↵
- 33.↵
- 34.↵
- British Orthopaedic Association
- 35.↵
- Government of Western Australia
- 36.↵
- Royal College of Physicians
- 37.↵
- Gupta A,
- Chenna S,
- Lorch A
- 38.↵
Article Tools
Citation Manager Formats
Jump to section
- Article
- ABSTRACT
- Introduction
- Benefits of geriatrician-led perioperative medical management
- Preoperative optimisation to enable early surgery
- Postoperative complications: early identification and management
- Other specialist roles of the orthogeriatrician working with hip fracture patients
- UK national standards approach
- First Acute Hip Unit in Wales
- Conclusions
- Acknowledgements
- References
- Info & Metrics
Related Articles
- No related articles found.