ABSTRACT
Syphilis is caused by the spirochete bacterium Treponema pallidum and can be transmitted both sexually and from mother to child. T pallidum can infect any organ and produces a clinical disease with a relapsing and remitting course. It is not hard to see, therefore, why it is often described as the great mimic. In this review, we provide an update of modern syphilis epidemiology, clinical presentations, and testing and treatment strategies.
The incidence of syphilis has increased significantly over the last 15 years. The majority of cases are among men who have sex with men (MSM) aged 25–35 of whom 40% are HIV positive.
Syphilis is a systemic disease from the outset and can involve any organ. It typically presents with a genital ulcer or a rash but its manifestations are protean.
For MSM presenting unwell with a rash, primary HIV infection is a key differential diagnosis and all patients with suspected syphilis should also be tested for HIV.
Diagnosis is confirmed serologically using two specific treponemal tests followed by a non-treponemal test to assess disease stage and to allow treatment monitoring.
Penicillin G treatment remains effective as does oral doxycycline, but macrolide antibiotics should be avoided due to widespread resistance.
Introduction
Syphilis is caused by the bacterium Treponema pallidum subspecies pallidum .1 This motile, gram-negative spirochete can be transmitted both sexually and from mother to child, and can invade virtually any organ or structure in the human body. The disease, which should be considered systemic throughout, is characterised by overlapping clinical stages and a relapsing and remitting course. This potentially diverse presentation led Sir William Osler to call syphilis ‘the great imitator’ and, together with a greatly increased incidence over the last 15 years, explains its importance to the general physician.
Epidemiology
Syphilis emerged in Europe after 1492 following the return of Columbus from the New World, although its presence in Europe prior to his return is still debated. Paleontological findings have been joined by data from gene sequence analysis of T pallidum subspecies and strains to both support and refute the ‘Columbian’ theory.1,2 No matter the origin, syphilis spread rapidly through Europe in the 15th century. By the end of Queen Victoria's reign, around 1:10 sexually active adults in London were thought to be infected, although the true prevalence wasn't known until the description of the first serologic test by Auguste Wasserman in 1906.3
Incidence in the UK declined greatly following the widespread use of penicillin in the early 1950s. Unfortunately, the last 15 years have seen a 10-fold increase in cases, with 4,317 reported new infections in 2014 – the highest for over 40 years. This rise is predominantly among men who have sex with men (MSM), who account for 80.6% of cases.4 Enhanced surveillance data show that the general profile is one of white MSM aged 25–34, reporting high numbers of sexual partners, condomless sex, recreational drug use and the use of social networking apps to find sexual partners. Approximately 40% are co-infected with HIV-1.5 Over a similar period, there has been a decline of 16% in female cases from 317 in 2003 to 265 in 2012. In 2011, the overall incidence of congenital syphilis in England was 0.0025/1,000 births. Cases predominated among women not accessing healthcare due to cultural barriers and social deprivation.6
Clinical presentation
The clinical course of syphilis is one of overlapping clinical stages which begin 9–90 (median 21) days following direct contact with an infectious lesion (Fig 1).
The clinical stages of syphilis. The clinical stages of syphilis from contact with T pallidum through to development of tertiary disease. During the first year of latent infection, 25% of patients will relapse to the secondary stage.
Primary syphilis
Primary syphilis is characterised by a papule at the point of entry of the bacterium that breaks down into an ulcer (chancre). Although classically anogenital, it can be in the mouth (30% of cases are transmitted through orogenital contact), rectum, cervix or other such clinically ‘quieter’ locations. A chancre is typically painless, 0.5–2 cm in diameter, firm or rubbery, and associated with regional lymphadenopathy (Fig 2). It usually heals over a 4–6 week period. Atypical presentations with multiple or painful ulcers can occur, especially in the context of HIV-1 co-infection.7 Important differential diagnoses are herpes simplex virus and lymphogranuloma venerum.
Clinical pictures of patients with early syphilis. Clinical photographs of patients with early syphilis: a) typical maculopapular rash on the chest; b) skin with secondary syphilis rash at high magnification; c) penile chancre. Images obtained from the Wellcome Photo Library (N0000562, N0000822 and N0000823) and reproduced with permission.
Secondary syphilis
The secondary stage of infection begins 4–10 weeks after the ulcer has healed, although this is highly variable and the primary and secondary stages can be concurrent. The hallmark sign is a maculopapular rash (seen in 50–70% of patients) that may affect the palms and soles (Fig 2).8 Other signs and symptoms are described in Table 1. The rash and especially the moist lesions of secondary syphilis are infectious. Given the shared epidemiology of HIV and syphilis, primary HIV infection is an important differential diagnosis in MSM presenting with a rash.
The clinical manifestations of syphilis.
Latent syphilis
In the absence of treatment, features of secondary syphilis typically regress within three months and the disease becomes latent and non-infectious. Clinical relapses may occur during the first two years of latency (early latent disease), but are rare thereafter (late latent disease).9
Tertiary disease
Following the latent stage (typically 15–30 years), signs and symptoms of tertiary infection may occur. These are now rare due to the lower prevalence of the disease 15–30 years ago and the widespread use of treponemocidal and treponemostatic antibiotics (penicillins, tetracyclines, macrolides, cephalosporins) for other infections. Tertiary disease is typically divided into gummatous (the most common), cardiovascular and neurological disease. Deep-seated and destructive gumma can occur in any organ but mainly affect the skin and bones. Cardiovascular syphilis mainly affects the aortic valve and ascending aorta most commonly causing aortic dilatation and regurgitation. Neurological features are discussed below.
Neurological involvement
Neurological involvement can occur at any stage. During the early stages of syphilis, the meninges, vasculature, cranial nerves (particularly II and VIII) and the eyes are most commonly affected. In the tertiary stage, the most common forms involve the brain and spinal cord parenchyma. Each form has characteristic clinical findings, although some overlap may occur (Table 1). All patients with suspected or confirmed syphilis and neurological symptoms should undergo a full neurological examination.9
Testing
Serologic tests can be used to diagnose all stages of syphilis. They consist of treponemal tests (TT) such as the Treponema pallidum particle agglutination (TPPA) assay or the IgM/IgG enzyme immunoassay (EIA) and non-treponemal (anti-cardiolipin) tests (NTT) such as rapid plasma reagin (RPR) or venereal disease research laboratory (VDRL) tests (NB VDRL testing is no longer widely available in the UK).10 TT are often the first to become positive (from two weeks after infection) and usually remain positive for life. NTT are performed quantitatively and are used to monitor treatment response. They give an indication of disease stage as higher titres are associated with more active (early) infection and lower titres indicate quieter (latent) or previously treated infection. NTT are subject to both biologic false positive (pregnancy, recent vaccination, autoimmune disease) and false negative (at very high titres due to a prozone phenomenon) results. It is also important to note that NTT may be negative in early primary infection.
There are two testing algorithms in use termed ‘conventional’ and ‘reverse’. The reverse algorithm is used in the UK and begins with an EIA followed by confirmation with a second TT (TPPA). Stage of disease is then assessed with the RPR titre.11 This method has the advantage of an automatable screening test (EIA) but can have a lower positive predictive value in low prevalence populations. It is noteworthy that other treponemal infections (yaws, pinta, bejel) are serologically indistinct from venereal syphilis.
Serologic tests can be performed on cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). A positive NTT is highly specific for neurosyphilis but lacks sensitivity. A negative TT on a CSF sample with a negligible red blood cell count (visible blood contamination can lead to false positive results) effectively excludes neurosyphilis.
In the genitourinary medicine (GUM) clinic, primary and secondary syphilis can also be diagnosed by the direct identification of T pallidum using darkground microscopy (DGM) or polymerase chain reaction (PCR).10 With optimal conditions, DGM can have a sensitivity of 80%.12 Due to contamination by commensal treponemes, such as Treponema denticola, the specificity of DGM for oral and rectal lesions is low. T pallidum PCR has a characteristically high sensitivity (80–100%) and specificity (92.1–99.8%).13
Management
Patients with signs or symptoms of syphilis should be referred to a GUM physician. The current recommended antimicrobial treatment of syphilis is well explained in the national treatment guideline.9 Basic management considerations are as follows.
Benzylpenicillin (penicillin G) was first used to treat syphilis in 1943 and penicillin is still the first-line treatment for all stages of syphilis.9 Duration and route vary according to stage but in the absence of neurological involvement depot parental preparations of penicillin are first line. In patients with allergy, doxycycline and ceftriaxone are alternative treatments.
Patients with syphilis are at risk of other sexually transmitted infections (STIs). A full sexual history should be taken and STI screening, including an HIV test, should be offered.
An RPR titre should be sent on the first day of treatment as a four-fold (two dilution) reduction in titre is the established serologic measure of treatment success.
Patients should abstain from sexual contact for two weeks following treatment for early syphilis.15 All sexual contacts within the last three months should be contacted and tested.
HIV-1 infected patients with CD4 counts <350 cells/ml and/or RPR titres ≥1:32 may be at increased risk of neurological involvement.
Patients with symptomatic disease should be warned about Jarisch–Herxheimer reaction (JHR) prior to treatment. The JHR is a self-limiting acute febrile illness which typically begins 12 hours after treatment and is complete 12 hours later.9 It is a particular concern in pregnancy and in patients with neurological or cardiovascular involvement.16 Steroids can be given before and during the first few days of treatment for neurological and cardiovascular syphilis. In most cases, rest and paracetamol suffice.
Antimicrobial resistance
Despite over 70 years of use, T pallidum remains sensitive to penicillin.17 Azithromycin was proven an effective treatment for early disease in two randomised controlled trials.18,19 Unfortunately, 60–80% of T pallidum strains in the UK are macrolide resistant thus it cannot be used reliably.20 As yet, there has been no description of tetracycline resistance in T pallidum.
Managing syphilis: a worked example
A 78 year-old Jamaican gentleman with memory impairment had syphilis serology sent as part of a dementia screen. The result returned as EIA positive, TPPA positive and RPR negative.
Key history
Where possible, take a sexual history in a confidential environment.14
Previous syphilis or syphilis treatment?
If yes, ascertain if this treatment was adequate (compliance, treatment given, partners treated?).
Previous syphilis testing? (NB For a female patient, syphilis testing may have been performed during antenatal screening).
If previously negative, then this could be new infection.
History of yaws (T pallidum subspecies pertenue) infection?
If yes, then serologic results may be secondary to yaws. If there is a clear history of treatment and the RPR is negative then patient may not require further treatment.
Previous symptoms consistent with primary or secondary syphilis? Current symptoms consistent with tertiary disease (other than memory impairment)?
Examination
Seek other signs of late neurosyphilis in addition to gummatous and cardiovascular disease. Be mindful of the possibility of late congenital syphilis, signs of which are detailed elsewhere.9
Management
Liaise with GUM team.
Relevant neurological signs should prompt CSF examination (with prior brain imaging such as CT or MRI). If the patient cannot tolerate lumbar puncture, then consider presumptive neurosyphilis treatment. This patient had a negative serum RPR, thus late neurosyphilis is highly unlikely.
Offer screening to past and present sexual partners (if contactable) and children if there is no evidence of the mother of the children being tested.
Conclusion
Syphilis has re-emerged as an important sexually transmitted infection. Timely diagnosis and treatment is necessary to prevent onward transmission and the development of irreversible tissue damage. Suspicion of the infection should prompt serologic testing and referral to a GUM physician.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Dr David Goldmeier for his helpful input during the preparation of this manuscript.
- © 2016 Royal College of Physicians
