Table 1.

Key design features of the RECOVERY trial, exemplifying the application of quality-by-design principles to clinical trials and the production of rapid, reliable results

Design featureRationale
Randomised
  • Avoidance of systematic error (bias).

Large
  • Avoidance of play of chance.

  • Provide adequate statistical power to detect moderate, but important, treatment effects across a broad range of circumstances.

Simple
  • Focus on critical components of quality that preserve safety and reliability.

  • Do not include extraneous procedures.

  • Streamlined study procedures at set-up, training, recruitment, randomisation, treatment delivery and follow-up facilitate timely results for patients and protect busy healthcare staff.

Inclusive
  • Facilitates prompt recruitment.

  • Provides translatable results for all patients (both in and outside the UK).

Objective clinical outcomes
  • Clinically relevant results.

  • Resistant to bias.

  • Allow data linkage for complete follow-up.

Linkage to national healthcare datasets
  • Reduced data collection by local research teams.

  • Complete follow-up improving study reliability.

  • Rapid collection of data to inform data monitoring committee analyses.

  • Low-cost long-term follow-up.

Collaborative
  • Buy-in from stakeholders at every level into study quality.

  • Transparency facilitates trust in study procedures, safety and results.

  • Resources are not wasted.

Robust web-based systems
  • Accessible to site staff.

  • Reliable randomisation.

  • Built-in options on online forms encourage consistency and completeness of data.

Data quality monitoring
  • Study procedures are subject to ongoing and continuous quality evaluation during the trial.

Trial oversight
  • Investigators at local hospital best placed to oversee high-quality study conduct locally.

  • Experienced data monitoring committee meeting regularly provide reassurances on efficacy, accountability and safety.