Strengths and limitations of early warning scores: A systematic review and narrative synthesis
Introduction
The early warning score system is predicated on the idea that derangements in simple physiological observations can identify hospital inpatients at high risk of deterioration (Goldhill and McNarry, 2004). Prodromal warning signs such as increased respiratory rate or decreased blood pressure precede critical illness (Ridley, 2005), and early recognition of these events presents an opportunity for decreasing mortality (Bleyer et al., 2011). The early warning score system allows the user to record and respond to multiple parameters simultaneously, so that subtle changes in vital signs can be used to initiate early emergency management of the patient to reverse the abnormal physiological decline or prompt admission to a critical care area (Ridley, 2005).
Early warning scores have been widely adopted internationally, and different versions exist. A number of reviews have examined the impact of early warning scores on patient outcomes; however, there exists no formal literature review regarding the overall strengths and limitations of early warning scores for patients, staff and systems. This review aims to address this knowledge gap and provide an overview of current systems, highlighting the benefits and identifying areas for future improvement.
Section snippets
Study design
A systematic review methodology was adopted for the study, employing the principles and methods provided by the Centre for Reviews and Dissemination guidelines and following the PRISMA statement. A narrative synthesis approach was chosen to synthesise the diverse range of selected studies in a structured manner, following the European Social Research Council Guidance on the Conduct of Narrative Synthesis in Systematic Reviews (Popay et al., 2006).
Search strategy
A systematic review of the scientific literature
Findings
The search identified 825 papers (285 Medline, 359 PubMed, 176 CINAHL and 5 Cochrane). Duplicates were eliminated. 232 papers met the inclusion criteria. A flow diagram of the search process is shown in Fig. 1.
There was 100% inter-rater agreement between CD and WT.
Prediction value
Early warning scores have consistently been found to accurately predict adverse outcomes in a number of different populations. Despite being developed for general medical hospital admissions, a recent retrospective study of 35 174 surgical admissions found that NEWS discriminated deterioration in non-elective surgical patients at least as well as in non-elective medical patients (Kovacs et al., 2016).
Early warning scores have been found to be excellent predictors of cardiac arrest (Churpek et
Sensitivity, especially compared to specialty-specific scores
In 2003, Boyle reported that early warning scoring systems were largely unproven and could prove to be over-sensitive and unspecific (Boyle, 2003). However, the evidence base has grown and a recent study from Hong Kong found that MEWS has a 100% sensitivity and a 98.3% specificity in detecting patient deterioration (Shuk-Ngor et al., 2015).
Nevertheless, early warning scores are generic tools which should be used to complement, but not necessarily replace, existing prediction tools (Barlow et
Discussion
This systematic review and narrative synthesis was conducted to explore the literature regarding the strengths and limitations of early warning score vital signs monitoring systems, for both patients and clinical teams. To our knowledge, this is the first literature review to systematically assess the extent of the evidence around these tools.
Early warning scores have become ubiquitous with the recognition of the deteriorating patient. This review confirms that early warning scores have
Conclusion
This review has shown that early warning scores are successful in predicting and improving patient outcomes across a range of settings and populations. The most important advantage of early warning scores is that they are easy to use and interpret, and so provide a common language across healthcare providers and specialties. However, inaccurate recordings or inappropriate reactions to abnormal scores can undermine the benefits of these systems.
Harnessing their strengths and recognizing their
Originality
This article is an original work, has not been published before, and is not being considered for publication elsewhere in its final form, in either printed or electronic media. It is not based on any previous communication to a society or meeting.
Funding sources
This review is independent research arising from a Doctoral Research Fellowship (Candice Downey, DRF-2016-09-03) supported by the National Institute for Health Research. The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NHS, the National Institute for Health Research, Health Education England or the Department of Health.
DGJ received funding support through an NIHR Research Professorship.
The authors acknowledge assistance from the NIHR Healthcare
References (117)
- et al.
Decision-tree early warning score (DTEWS) validates the design of the national early warning score (NEWS)
Resuscitation
(2014) - et al.
Assessment of clinical risk in the out of hours hospital prior to the introduction of hospital at night
Acute Med.
(2009) - et al.
Longitudinal analysis of one million vital signs in patients in an academic medical center
Resuscitation
(2011) - et al.
Mobility measures should be added to the national early warning score (NEWS)
Resuscitation
(2014) - et al.
Lower incidence of unexpected in-hospital death after interprofessional implementation of a bedside track-and-trigger system
Resuscitation
(2014) - et al.
Predicting cardiac arrest on the wards: a nested case-control study
Chest
(2012) - et al.
Is the modified early warning score (MEWS) superior to clinician judgement in detecting critical illness in the pre-hospital environment?
Resuscitation
(2012) - et al.
Preoperative early warning scores can predict in-hospital mortality and critical care admission following emergency surgery
J. Surg. Res.
(2010) - et al.
Physiological abnormalities in early warning scores are related to mortality in adult inpatients
Br. J. Anaesth.
(2004) - et al.
Intensive care unit without walls: seeking patient safety by improving the efficiency of the system
Med. Intensiva
(2014)
Bedside electronic capture of clinical observations and automated clinical alerts to improve compliance with an Early Warning Score protocol
Crit. Care Resuscitation
Validation of an abbreviated VitalpacTM Early Warning Score (ViEWS) in 75,419 consecutive admissions to a Canadian regional hospital
Resuscitation
Changes and their prognostic implications in the abbreviated VitalPACTM Early Warning Score (ViEWS) after admission to hospital of 18,827 surgical patients
Resuscitation
Factors affecting response to national early warning score (NEWS)
Resuscitation
Long-term effect of introducing an early warning score on respiratory rate charting on general wards
Resuscitation
Developing nursing students' decision making skills: are early warning scoring systems helpful?
Nurse Educ. Pract.
An eight year audit before and after the introduction of modified early warning score (MEWS) charts, of patients admitted to a tertiary referral intensive care unit after CPR
Resuscitation
The effect of a critical care outreach service and an early warning scoring system on respiratory rate recording on the general wards
Resuscitation
Validation of the VitalPAC Early Warning Score (ViEWS) in acutely ill medical patients attending a resource-poor hospital in sub-Saharan Africa
Resuscitation
Serious adverse events in a hospital using early warning score—what went wrong?
Resuscitation
Calculating early warning scores–a classroom comparison of pen and paper and hand-held computer methods
Resuscitation
Use of an early warning score and ability to walk predicts mortality in medical patients admitted to hospitals in Tanzania
Trans. R. Soc. Trop. Med. Hygiene
Predictors of early mortality among hospitalized nursing home residents
QJM
Early warning score in primary care in Denmark
Ugeskr. Laeger
Packaging: a grounded theory of how to report physiological deterioration effectively
J. Adv. Nurs.
Early warning systems: scorecards that save lives
Mo. Nurse
Expanded MEWS is more predictive: updates seen as more appropriate for ED
ED Manag.
Private homes should adopt NHS system
Nurs. Stand.
Scores give us ammunition when referring patients
Nurs. Stand.
Sepsis screening
Nursing Manage. (Lond., Engl.: 1994)
Predictive value of the modified Early Warning Score in a Turkish emergency department
Eur. J. Emerg. Med.
A simple prognostic index based on admission vital signs data among patients with sepsis in a resource-limited setting
Crit. Care
Using a local early warning scoring system as a model for the introduction of a national system
Acute Med.
Single deranged physiologic parameters are associated with mortality in a low-income country
Crit. Care Med.
The CURB65 pneumonia severity score outperforms generic sepsis and early warning scores in predicting mortality in community-acquired pneumonia
Thorax
An early warning scoring system to identify septic patients in the prehospital setting: the PRESEP score
Acad. Emerg. Med.
A controlled trial of electronic automated advisory vital signs monitoring in general hospital wards
Crit. Care Med.
Impact of critical care reconfiguration and track-and-trigger outreach team intervention on outcomes of haematology patients requiring intensive care admission
Ann. Hematol.
The digital patient
Clin. Med.
Critical care outreach service
N2N: Nurse2Nurse
The comparison of modified early warning score with rapid emergency medicine score: a prospective multicentre observational cohort study on medical and surgical patients presenting to emergency department
Emerg. Med. J.
Modified early warning score predicts the need for hospital admission and inhospital mortality
Emerg. Med. J.
A new approach to scoring systems to improve identification of acute medical admissions that will require critical care
Scott. Med. J.
Physiological observations and early warning scoring tools within the deployed field hospital
J. R. Army Med. Corps
THERM: the Resuscitation Management score. A prognostic tool to identify critically ill patients in the emergency department
Emerg. Med. J.
In-hospital mortality and morbidity of elderly medical patients can be predicted at admission by the modified early warning score: a prospective study
Int. J. Clin. Pract.
Physiological scoring: an aid to emergency medical services transport decisions?
Prehospital Disaster Med.
Attitudes of nursing staff towards a modified early warning system
Br. J. Nurs.
Nurse-administered early warning score system can be used for emergency department triage
Dan. Med. Bull.
Low compliance with a validated system for emergency department triage
Dan. Med. Bull.
Cited by (154)
The Effect of Modified Early Warning Score (MEWS) and Nursing Guide Application on Postoperative Patient Outcomes: A Randomized Controlled Study
2024, Journal of Perianesthesia NursingUtopia versus dystopia: Professional perspectives on the impact of healthcare artificial intelligence on clinical roles and skills
2023, International Journal of Medical InformaticsSYSTEMS-BASED PHYSICAL ASSESSMENTS: EARLIER DETECTION OF CLINICAL DETERIORATION AND REDUCED MORTALITY
2023, American Journal of Critical CareWireless patient monitoring and Efficacy Safety Score in postoperative treatment at the ward: evaluation of time consumption and usability
2024, Journal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing